What a Marketing Agency for Musicians Should Deliver in the First 90 Days
- Doc. N°
- ELMTM-075
- Filed
- Class
- Music
- By
- Ethan Leard-Means
- Read
- 8 min
Most artists who hire marketing help are buying a schedule. A posting calendar, a release plan, a playlist pitch, perhaps a small ad budget pointed at a new single. A quarter later there is a report full of streams, saves and follower growth, and the artist still cannot answer three basic questions: who are my fans, how do I reach them without an algorithm's permission, and which of them buy anything?
That is not a content problem. It is an infrastructure problem. Streams and followers are reach. Revenue happens somewhere else: at a merch checkout, a ticket page, a direct-to-fan offer, an email that arrives on announcement day. If none of those paths has been built, more content simply sends more attention to places where it cannot be collected. The first ninety days of any engagement with a marketing agency for musicians should build those paths before a single dollar goes into campaigns.
The platform owns the relationship, not you
Start with what an artist actually controls. On Spotify, a follow is valuable: Spotify's own documentation says followers receive new releases through surfaces such as Release Radar. But the same page is explicit about the limit. In Spotify for Artists, you can see the total number of followers, but you cannot see the names of individual followers. The audience is real, and it belongs to the platform.
Every social and streaming platform works the same way in principle. Reach is rented. The terms, the feed and the distribution rules can change without notice, and the artist cannot export the people behind the numbers. An artist whose entire audience lives inside platforms has a large audience and no list.
This is the first thing an agency should diagnose, and most never ask. How many fans can you contact directly today, by email or text, without paying a platform to show them a post? For many working artists the honest answer is close to none.
Streaming income is one line, not the business
Spotify itself frames streaming as part of the picture rather than the whole. Its royalty transparency site notes that streaming makes up only a portion of all industry revenues, and lists physical sales, touring, merch and sync alongside it. The same page reports that Spotify has paid out nearly $70 billion to artists, songwriters and rightsholders to date. That total is paid to rights holders, not to individual artists, and it is one revenue stream among several.
The practical consequence is simple. For most independent and developing artists, the revenue lines they control most directly are the ones the stream count does not measure: shows, merch, physical releases, fan offers and bookings. A marketing plan that reports streams as the primary outcome is measuring the line the artist influences least.
What the first ninety days should produce
A competent engagement front-loads infrastructure. Campaign spend comes after. Three deliverables matter more than any content calendar.
1. Owned audience capture
The first deliverable is a working way to turn listeners into contacts. That means an email list, and where it fits, a text list, with a clear reason to join: presale access, early announcements, a release-day note, something a fan actually wants. Capture points should exist everywhere attention already lands: the link in bio, the website, the merch checkout, the ticket confirmation, the merch table at shows.
This is also where the rules start. Commercial email in the United States falls under the CAN-SPAM Act, which requires, among other things, a valid physical postal address of the sender and that opt-out requests be honored within 10 business days. Text messaging carries its own consent requirements, which should be reviewed with counsel before any SMS program goes live. An agency that builds a list without building it correctly is creating a liability, not an asset.
2. A merch and ticket path that starts where fans listen
The second deliverable is a path from listening to buying that does not depend on a fan going looking. The platforms provide much of this already, and many artists leave it unused.
Spotify for Artists lets an artist connect a Shopify store and sell merch directly to fans. Once connected, Spotify says an artist can publish up to 250 merch items, which fans can find on the artist profile, release pages, the Now Playing view and the artist store page. Concerts work similarly: Spotify imports shows automatically from its listed ticketing partners and recommends them to fans based on where they live and who they follow and listen to. Songkick listings and virtual events are not displayed.
None of that is a strategy on its own. But an artist whose store is not connected, or whose shows are listed with a ticketing provider the platform does not import, has a leak at the exact moment a listener is most engaged. Closing those gaps is mechanical work, and it belongs in the first month, not the fourth.
The artist's own website is the other half of the path. It should carry the current release, the next show, the store and the list signup, and each of those should be one step from the homepage. A site built as a press kit tends to fail all four.
3. A measurement baseline
The third deliverable is a baseline, recorded before any campaign starts. Without it, nothing that follows can be judged. At minimum it should capture the size of the email and text lists, monthly merch orders and revenue, ticket sales by market, website traffic by source, and current streaming listeners and followers from Spotify for Artists.
Attribution needs to be wired at the same time. Google Analytics collects campaign data from parameters added to a link, so every link the artist controls should be tagged: utm_source for the referrer, utm_medium for the marketing medium and utm_campaign for the campaign. Links in bio, release emails, show announcements and ads should each carry their own tags, so a merch order or ticket sale can be traced back to the post or message that sent it. Without tagged links, every result after launch is a guess.
Why campaigns come after
Campaign spend before infrastructure has a predictable outcome. Paid promotion of a single drives streams, which drive followers, which the artist cannot contact. A tour announcement goes out to a feed that shows it to a fraction of followers, and the artist has no list to send it to directly. A merch drop gets attention on social and loses it at a checkout that takes four clicks to find.
Run in the other order, the same campaign does different work. Ads and content send traffic to a capture point. Every new contact can be reached for the next release, the next show and the next drop at no additional platform cost. Ticket and merch sales can be traced back to the posts and messages that produced them. The campaign becomes an input to a system rather than a one-off expense.
What to do
If you are hiring marketing help, or evaluating the help you have, ask for these by the end of the first ninety days:
- A list. A working email signup, and where appropriate a compliant text signup, with a clear reason to join and capture points on every surface where fans already find you.
- A connected store. Merch linked to your streaming profiles where the platform supports it, and a site where the store is one step from the homepage.
- Visible shows. Every date listed with a ticketing provider your streaming platforms import, and a site that shows the next date without searching.
- Tagged links. A consistent tagging convention for every link you post or send, so sales can be traced to sources.
- A written baseline. List size, merch revenue, ticket sales, traffic by source and streaming numbers, recorded before campaign spend begins.
If an agency's first-quarter plan is mostly content and playlist pitching, ask where the fans it reaches will be stored, and how you will know which of them bought something. If there is no answer, the plan is reach without a destination.
Where this fits
This is how ELM Tree Marketing approaches music clients: build the system first, then scale what flows through it. Our music practice applies the same sequence we use across every vertical: strategy and diagnosis, then the conversion paths, then acquisition, then retention through the channels an artist owns. We have also written about what a music marketing agency should do for revenue rather than streams. If you want to know where your own audience is leaking before you spend on another campaign, apply for a Growth Analysis.
FAQ
What should a marketing agency for musicians deliver first?
Infrastructure before campaigns: a way to capture fans as email and text contacts, a merch and ticket path that starts where fans already listen, and a written measurement baseline recorded before any spend.
Why are streaming followers not enough on their own?
Followers live inside the platform. Spotify shows artists how many followers they have but not who those followers are, so an artist cannot contact them directly or carry them to another channel.
Should musicians run ads before building an email list?
Generally not. Ads that send listeners to a stream or a profile build reach the artist cannot contact later. Ads that send listeners to a signup, a store or a ticket page build an audience the artist owns.
How should an artist measure whether marketing is working?
Record a baseline first, including list size, merch revenue, ticket sales, website traffic by source and streaming numbers, and tag every link with campaign parameters so sales can be traced back to the post or message that produced them.